Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson
Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson is a Muncie, IN taco spot in the Westside area known for Mexican food, casual Mexican fare, and a neighborhood restaurant feel, with a 4.4★ rating across 1,942 Google reviews.
Best for
Why people love this place
- •Highly rated by locals
- •Affordable, everyday pricing
- •Good for casual tacos
- •Located in Westside, Muncie
- •Strong Google review volume
Order like a local
- →Order a sampler — two or three different fillings — to find your favorite.
- →Try at least one of the house salsas. Ask which is the spiciest.
- →Cash often moves the line faster at casual taquerías like this.
- →It can get busy at peak hours — aim for early lunch or mid-afternoon.
Good to know
Frequently asked
What kind of tacos does Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson serve?+
Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson is known for classic Mexican tacos, plus the usual taquería staples like rice, beans, and house salsas.
Where is Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson located?+
Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson is at 508 S Tillotson Ave, Muncie, IN 47304, USA, in the Westside neighborhood of Muncie, Indiana.
Is Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson good?+
Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson has a 4.4★ average across 1,942 Google reviews — highly rated by Muncie taco standards.
How expensive is Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson?+
Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson sits at $ (cheap eats) — typical for a Muncie taquería.
Taco Love Feed
Community posts · separate from GoogleBe the first Taco Lover to post what you ordered here.
Share a photo and a quick take — help the next taco hunter pick a winner.
- • What taco did you order?
- • Was the salsa worth it?
- • Would you bring a friend?
- • Best time to go?
More in Muncie
La Glorieta
, Muncie · $$ · 165 reviews
View Taco Joint
Elm Street Brewing Company
, Muncie · $$ · 1,198 reviews
“Laid-back brewpub featuring a wide selection of craft beers, plus classic pub fare & live music.”
View Taco Joint
Salsa’s Mexican Grill Express
Thomas Park - Avondale, Muncie · $$ · 542 reviews
View Taco JointLooking for tacos in Muncie?
Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson is one of many great taco spots in Muncie, Indiana. Browse the full guide to Muncie taco joints, including more options near Westside, or map a weekend taco road trip across the region.