Old Pueblo Grill — tacos in Rochester, NY

Old Pueblo Grill

4.4· 1,188 Google reviews·$$·Neighborhood of the Arts

Old Pueblo Grill is a Rochester, NY taco spot in the Neighborhood of the Arts area known for Mexican food, casual Mexican fare, and a neighborhood restaurant feel, with a 4.4★ rating across 1,188 Google reviews.

Rating
4.4
Highly rated
Reviews
1,188
Google reviews
Price
$$
Mid-range
Known for
Mexican
Casual tacos

Best for

Group dinnerSit-down meal

Why people love this place

  • •Highly rated by locals
  • •Reasonable mid-range pricing
  • •Good for casual tacos
  • •Located in Neighborhood of the Arts, Rochester
  • •Strong Google review volume

Order like a local

  • →Order a sampler — two or three different fillings — to find your favorite.
  • →Try at least one of the house salsas. Ask which is the spiciest.
  • →It can get busy at peak hours — aim for early lunch or mid-afternoon.

Good to know

Cuisine
Mexican
Vibe
Sit-down restaurant
Neighborhood
Neighborhood of the Arts, Rochester
Good for
Walk-ins, takeout
Bring
Cards usually accepted

Frequently asked

What kind of tacos does Old Pueblo Grill serve?+

Old Pueblo Grill is known for classic Mexican tacos, plus the usual taquería staples like rice, beans, and house salsas.

Where is Old Pueblo Grill located?+

Old Pueblo Grill is at 55 Russell St, Rochester, NY 14607, USA, in the Neighborhood of the Arts neighborhood of Rochester, New York.

Is Old Pueblo Grill good?+

Old Pueblo Grill has a 4.4★ average across 1,188 Google reviews — highly rated by Rochester taco standards.

How expensive is Old Pueblo Grill?+

Old Pueblo Grill sits at $$ (mid-range) — typical for a Rochester taquería.

Taco Love Feed

Community posts · separate from Google
Log in to share a taco moment. A photo is required for every post.
🌮

Be the first Taco Lover to post what you ordered here.

Share a photo and a quick take — help the next taco hunter pick a winner.

  • • What taco did you order?
  • • Was the salsa worth it?
  • • Would you bring a friend?
  • • Best time to go?
Log in to post

More in Rochester

Tavos Antojitos y Tequila — tacos in Rochester, NY

Tavos Antojitos y Tequila

4.5

North Winton Village, Rochester · $$ · 580 reviews

View Taco Joint

Looking for tacos in Rochester?

Old Pueblo Grill is one of many great taco spots in Rochester, New York. Browse the full guide to Rochester taco joints, including more options near Neighborhood of the Arts, or map a weekend taco road trip across the region.

Explore more