Matty's Bar & Grille — tacos in New Berlin, WI

Matty's Bar & Grille

4.6· 3,018 Google reviews·$$

Matty's Bar & Grille is a New Berlin, WI taco spot known for Mexican food, casual Mexican fare, and a neighborhood restaurant feel, with a 4.6★ rating across 3,018 Google reviews.

Rating
4.6
Loved by locals
Reviews
3,018
Google reviews
Price
$$
Mid-range
Known for
Mexican
Casual tacos

Best for

Group dinnerSit-down meal

Why people love this place

  • •Highly rated by locals
  • •Reasonable mid-range pricing
  • •Good for casual tacos
  • •Located in New Berlin, WI
  • •Strong Google review volume

Order like a local

  • →Order a sampler — two or three different fillings — to find your favorite.
  • →Try at least one of the house salsas. Ask which is the spiciest.
  • →It can get busy at peak hours — aim for early lunch or mid-afternoon.

Good to know

Cuisine
Mexican
Vibe
Sit-down restaurant
Good for
Walk-ins, takeout
Bring
Cards usually accepted

Frequently asked

What kind of tacos does Matty's Bar & Grille serve?+

Matty's Bar & Grille is known for classic Mexican tacos, plus the usual taquería staples like rice, beans, and house salsas.

Where is Matty's Bar & Grille located?+

Matty's Bar & Grille is at 14460 College Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151, USA in New Berlin, Wisconsin.

Is Matty's Bar & Grille good?+

Matty's Bar & Grille has a 4.6★ average across 3,018 Google reviews — loved by locals by New Berlin taco standards.

How expensive is Matty's Bar & Grille?+

Matty's Bar & Grille sits at $$ (mid-range) — typical for a New Berlin taquería.

Taco Love Feed

Community posts · separate from Google
Log in to share a taco moment. A photo is required for every post.
🌮

Be the first Taco Lover to post what you ordered here.

Share a photo and a quick take — help the next taco hunter pick a winner.

  • • What taco did you order?
  • • Was the salsa worth it?
  • • Would you bring a friend?
  • • Best time to go?
Log in to post

More in New Berlin

Cocina Real — tacos in New Berlin, WI

Cocina Real

4.3

, New Berlin · $$ · 1,182 reviews

“Casual, traditional restaurant offering a wide menu of popular Mexican dishes & margaritas.”

View Taco Joint
Señor Luna — tacos in New Berlin, WI

Señor Luna

4.4

, New Berlin · $$ · 898 reviews

“An easygoing setting with Mexican fare known for fajitas & happy hour with a wrap-around bar.”

View Taco Joint

Looking for tacos in New Berlin?

Matty's Bar & Grille is one of many great taco spots in New Berlin, Wisconsin. Browse the full guide to New Berlin taco joints or map a weekend taco road trip across the region.

Explore more